For decades, paleontology students have been shown the uintatheres as a clear lesson in sexual dimorphism, the term for physical differences between the males and females of a species. These were enormous plant-eaters with knobby horns and long canine teeth, and the standard interpretation held that the males were much bigger than the females, with far more dramatic skulls.

A study from the University of Kansas, published in PLOS One, has put that interpretation to a statistical test, and it largely fails. The differences between male and female uintatheres appear to be much smaller than paleontologists long believed, if they can be detected at all.

“Maybe there were some little signals of dimorphism here and there,” said Kevin Mulcahy, a doctoral student at the university’s Biodiversity Institute and Natural History Museum and the study’s author. They were weak and inconsistent, he found, and nothing like the stark division the textbooks describe.

A Broken Tooth and a Drawer of Skulls

Uintatheres first appear in the fossil record about 58 million years ago, less than 10 million years after the asteroid impact that ended the age of the dinosaurs, and they persisted for roughly another 20 million years. They were among the first truly large mammals.

The project started by accident. Mulcahy and his adviser, K. Christopher Beard, a senior curator at the museum, were trying to identify a broken upper molar collected during fieldwork in Montana that looked as though it might belong to a uintathere. They went to the American Museum of Natural History in New York to compare it with other specimens.

While he was there, Mulcahy noticed something about the skulls, each of which is nearly a meter long. They varied a great deal, but the variation did not sort into two obvious types. He took out a ruler, recorded their dimensions and checked whether the numbers fell into a single bell-shaped spread or into two clusters, as would be expected if the animals came in a large sex and a small sex. They did not form two groups.

Testing the Method on Bison

He then widened the sample, gathering measurements from other institutions and applying newer statistical techniques. The final dataset covered about 30 skulls of a single species, Uintatherium anceps. The result was the same: only faint and inconsistent hints of dimorphism.

Mulcahy recognized two problems with stopping there. One is built into the subject. Nobody knows the sex of a fossil, so assigning sexes on the basis of size and then testing whether the sexes differ in size is circular. The other was the possibility that his methods simply were not sensitive enough to pick up a real difference.

To check, he ran the same analysis on modern bison, large horned herbivores thought to fill an ecological role similar to that of uintatheres, and animals whose sex is known. The bison showed a much clearer signal. Females grouped with females and males with males. The method could find dimorphism where it existed. It just did not find much in Uintatherium.

Whose Assumption Was It?

If the evidence was always this thin, why did the idea take hold? Mulcahy argues that the answer may lie with the scientists more than the fossils. The uintatheres were described in the late 19th and early 20th centuries by paleontologists who were almost all men, working at a time when evolutionary theory and the concept of sexual selection were new. An expectation that males would be the larger and more ornamented sex, he suggests, reflects that cultural outlook.

The implications extend past one extinct group. If a showcase example turns out to be weak, other fossil species assumed to be strongly dimorphic may deserve a second look. Mulcahy says pronounced male-biased dimorphism was probably not the ancestral condition in mammals and has more likely evolved independently several times. He points to a recent paper finding that in most living mammal species the sexes are either the same size or the females are larger. The belief that males are bigger, in his view, says more about which animals scientists have chosen to study.

The usual caveats for fossil studies apply. Thirty skulls is a modest sample, though large for an animal of this size and age, and a weak signal is not proof of no difference. The claim about historical bias is an interpretation, not something the measurements can demonstrate.


Endnotes

  1. Mulcahy, K. (2026). Study of sexual dimorphism in Uintatherium anceps. PLOS One. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0345236
  2. University of Kansas (October 7, 2026). “Study: ‘Classic example’ of sexual dimorphism in fossil record actually shows nuance between males and females.” EurekAlert! https://www.eurekalert.org/news-releases/1146156

Leave a Reply

Trending