A child sitting alone at recess tends to set off alarms for parents and teachers. A study from the University of Georgia suggests the worry is sometimes misplaced. Some children who seem unsociable are simply content with their own company, and what protects them from loneliness is a belief that they belong.

The research, published in The Elementary School Journal, found that solitary children who valued belonging, and who trusted that classmates would keep inviting them to play even if they sometimes said no, were comfortable with their peers. Solitary children who did not think fitting in mattered fared worse. They tended to turn invitations down until the invitations stopped coming, and then felt left out.

473 Fourth and Fifth Graders

The team surveyed 473 fourth and fifth graders at several elementary schools in Georgia. Classmates identified peers who preferred to play alone even though they got along well with others, a pattern psychologists call unsociable withdrawal. The children also rated how much they valued belonging and described the quality of their one-on-one friendships and of their relationships in larger groups, such as their class.

The age was chosen deliberately. By fourth and fifth grade, peer groups are more settled, social skills are stronger and children have more experience with one another, said Rachael Pfanz, the study’s corresponding author, a doctoral graduate of the university’s Mary Frances Early College of Education who now works as an elementary school psychologist. That makes it easier to see who is regularly alone or drifting into isolation.

Two Kinds of Solitude

Children whom classmates labeled “not social” were often unhappy with their standing in class. They described sitting alone at lunch and not being picked first for reading groups. Many still had good one-on-one friendships, but navigating groups is an important skill in childhood, and that is where they struggled.

Belief in belonging divided them. Children who did not value belonging were dissatisfied with their peers both in friendships and across the class. The researchers suspect these children decline more invitations, withdraw further and become steadily more isolated.

Children who valued belonging but still spent much of their time alone were at ease at both levels. The researchers think they accept enough invitations to feel included and decline others without anxiety, because they expect more to come. These children prefer solitude yet still get along well with others, Pfanz said, and their sense of belonging motivates them to join in some activities even when they might rather not.

Michele Lease, a professor of educational psychology and a co-author, compared social engagement to exercise and healthy eating, things people do because they are good for them even when they would rather not. “Turning down invitations, like avoiding exercise, leads to poorer outcomes,” she said.

Small Groups, Not the Big Game

The practical advice is to reassure children that they fit in without forcing them into interaction they do not want. Teachers and parents should keep the findings in mind when planning group activities and before pushing a solitary child into a situation they would prefer to avoid.

Pfanz cautions against sending a quiet child straight into a large playground game, which can feel overwhelming. “Instead, encourage those solo kids to go join a small group” of peers with similar interests, she said, and see how it goes. Gentle nudges of that kind, or occasional encouragement to accept an invitation, can help build social skills.

The study is based on surveys taken at one point in time, so its account of how withdrawal and belonging feed into each other is the researchers’ interpretation, not something the data follow over months or years. The university’s summary does not report effect sizes. The co-authors also include Michael Barger, Stacey Neuharth-Pritchett and Mihyun Kim of the university’s educational psychology department.


Endnotes

  1. Pfanz, R., Lease, M., Barger, M., Neuharth-Pritchett, S., Kim, M., et al. (June 24, 2026). “Belief in the Importance of Belonging Mitigates the Negative Effects of Unsociable Withdrawal.” The Elementary School Journal. https://doi.org/10.1086/742021
  2. University of Georgia (August 10, 2026). “Unsocial kids may be happier than you think.” EurekAlert! https://www.eurekalert.org/news-releases/1139553

Leave a Reply

Trending