The COVID-19 pandemic weighed on nearly everyone’s mental health, but not equally. A study following thousands of American adults from 2019 into 2024 finds that people high in neuroticism, the personality trait tied to worry and emotional sensitivity, suffered a much sharper rise in distress when the pandemic hit, and that a gap between them and their calmer peers was still visible four years later.

The research, published in PLOS One by economists and psychologists at the University of Southern California and two universities in Rome, also tracked how the more neurotic participants behaved. They perceived greater risks, exercised and relaxed less often, and drank alcohol more often.

Five Years, 4,000 People

The data come from the Understanding America Study, a USC survey panel of about 14,000 U.S. adults recruited to be nationally representative. The analysis covered 4,030 adults and more than 106,000 survey responses. A dedicated COVID survey ran in 34 rounds from March 2020 to mid-2023, supplemented by surveys taken before the pandemic and another in early 2024.

Distress was measured with the PHQ-4, a four-question screening tool that asks how often over the past two weeks a person has felt down, lost interest in things, felt nervous or been unable to stop worrying. Scores run from 0 to 12, and 6 or higher signals moderate to severe symptoms of depression or anxiety. Personality had been assessed before the pandemic with a standard 44-item questionnaire covering the Big Five traits. The researchers compared the most neurotic quarter of participants with the least neurotic quarter, adjusting for age, gender and income.

A Gap That Never Closed

Across the whole sample, distress jumped in March 2020, eased somewhat, and remained above 2019 levels through early 2024. Distress had already been rising before COVID, however, so the pandemic may not account for all of the lasting increase.

The most neurotic quarter fared worst. In the early pandemic their scores rose about 1.1 points more than those of the least neurotic quarter, a difference equal to roughly 70 percent of the group’s average score before the pandemic. The gap narrowed over time but never disappeared, and the same pattern held for the share of people crossing the threshold of 6 points. It looked broadly similar among younger, middle-aged and older adults.

The other four traits mattered far less. Conscientiousness offered modest protection, most clearly among adults 60 and older, while extraversion, openness and agreeableness showed weak or inconsistent links to distress.

Worry, Exercise and Alcohol

Participants high in neuroticism rated their chances of dying from COVID, losing their jobs or running out of money as higher. Those worries peaked during surges of infection and faded only gradually. The same people reported more handwashing, mask wearing and avoidance of public places through fall 2021, when the survey stopped asking. Avoiding crowds appeared largely tied to their fears, but handwashing and masking were not fully explained by fear.

They also relaxed and exercised less and drank more often. The study documents those associations but cannot establish why they occurred.

Check In, Don’t Treat Everyone

The authors draw a measured conclusion. Most highly neurotic participants never reached clinical levels of distress, and they describe the trait as “a risk factor, not a determinant.” On that basis they argue that blanket preventive therapy for everyone who scores high on neuroticism would be inappropriate. Their recommendation is to check in with such people once a crisis begins and reserve intensive treatment for those whose distress persists.

They also list the study’s limits. The PHQ-4 relies on self-report and is a screening tool, not a diagnosis. The results are correlational. Neuroticism may travel with other circumstances, such as denser urban living or less secure employment, that affect distress independently. The data say nothing about whether participants used mental health services, and the analysis covers only the United States.

The authors are Marco Angrisani and Wรคndi Bruine de Bruin of USC, Vincenzo Atella of the University of Rome Tor Vergata and Joanna Kopinska of Sapienza University of Rome. Angrisani received funding from the National Institute on Aging.


Endnotes

  1. Angrisani, M., Atella, V., Bruine de Bruin, W., & Kopinska, J. (2026). “How personality traits shape susceptibility to mental distress in times of crisis: Evidence from the COVID-19 pandemic.” PLOS One, 21(10), e0358371. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0358371
  2. PLOS (October 7, 2026). Press release on neuroticism and distress during the COVID-19 pandemic. EurekAlert! https://www.eurekalert.org/news-releases/1145997
  3. StudyFinds (2026). Coverage of the PLOS One study on neuroticism and COVID-era distress. https://studyfinds.com/worriers-anxious-4-years-after-covid/

Leave a Reply

Trending