Every animal embryo faces an early and unforgiving decision: which end will be the head and which the tail. In the fruit fly Drosophila melanogaster, the answer is one of the best-known stories in developmental biology. A gene called bicoid, supplied by the mother and concentrated at one end of the egg, marks the front and sets the rest of the body plan in motion.

There is an awkward fact behind that textbook account. Most flies do not have bicoid. The gene exists in only some fly species, yet every fly manages to build a head at one end and a tail at the other.

A study published in August in PLOS Biology by researchers at the University of Chicago shows how one of those other flies does it. The moth fly Clogmia albipunctata relies on a different gene, working through different targets, to reach the same outcome. The species is better known as the drain fly, a harmless insect whose dense coat of hair gives it the look of a tiny moth and which turns up in warm, damp places such as drains, plant pots and restrooms.

Urs Schmidt-Ott, a professor of organismal biology and anatomy at Chicago and the study’s senior author, said the absence of bicoid from most flies, despite its importance in Drosophila, is what sent his group looking for its counterparts elsewhere. “It turns out each of these other species has its own interesting story,” he said.

A Gene With a Second Job

In 2019, Schmidt-Ott’s team identified three unrelated genes that do the work of bicoid in other fly lineages. All three are more widely conserved across insects than bicoid itself. Since then the lab has been building genetic tools for species that lack the fruit fly’s long history as a laboratory animal, with the aim of learning whether the substitute genes behave like bicoid or operate by some other mechanism.

In the moth fly, the substitute is a gene called odd-paired. It already has a day job. In both moth fly and fruit fly embryos, odd-paired helps ensure that the larva forms the correct number of body segments. Moth fly mothers, however, also switch the gene on earlier, while the egg is still forming. That early transcript yields an almost identical protein, but it appears at a different time and in a different place: the region of the egg that will become the head.

The researchers see a general pattern in cases like this. A single gene can produce more than one version of its message, known as alternative transcript isoforms, and evolution can recruit one of those versions as a new signal for the embryo’s gene network. The original function carries on undisturbed.

Opening the Genome at One End

The new work asks how odd-paired acts at the molecular level. The answer involves chromatin, the combination of DNA and proteins packed inside the nucleus. Where chromatin is loosely packed, or open, genes can be read. Where it is tightly packed, they are largely out of reach.

Both bicoid and the moth fly’s odd-paired break the embryo’s symmetry in a similar way, by opening chromatin at genes that promote head development, and doing so at only one end of the egg. The genes they open are not the same. Bicoid directly regulates dozens of targets, the most thoroughly studied being a gene called hunchback. The moth fly’s odd-paired does not appear to act on hunchback at all. Instead, moth fly embryos begin building a head by activating two other genes, homeobrain and sloppy-paired.

Biologists have a name for this kind of divergence: developmental systems drift. The underlying gene networks wander apart over evolutionary time while the result they produce, in this case an embryo with a front and a back, stays the same. The fly head-to-tail axis is an unusually stark example, because the gene at the very top of the hierarchy has been swapped out more than once.

A Hundred and Fifty Thousand Experiments

Open questions remain. It is not yet clear whether homeobrain and sloppy-paired are enough on their own to break symmetry in most flies, or whether the earliest embryonic networks vary widely from one lineage to the next. The group plans to compare developmental gene networks across many species to find out which features resist change, and why.

Schmidt-Ott argued that comparisons of this kind are worth the effort even when a model as well understood as Drosophila is available, because they show how nature has solved the same problem in different lineages. There are roughly 150,000 described species of flies, he noted, with considerable variation in how they establish head-to-tail polarity. Each amounts to a natural experiment in how such mechanisms work and how they change.

The study’s authors also include researchers from the Illinois Institute of Technology, the University of Notre Dame and Northwestern University. The work was funded by the National Institute of General Medical Sciences, part of the National Institutes of Health.


Endnotes

  1. Amiri, E. E., Li, M., Tenger-Trolander, A., Devine, M., Kasan, K., Julian, A. T., Sanders, S. A., Blythe, S. A., & Schmidt-Ott, U. (2026). “Asymmetric chromatin accessibility underlies anterior-posterior axis specification in moth fly embryos.” PLOS Biology. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pbio.3003896
  2. University of Chicago (August 6, 2026). “Different genes, same result: How flies evolved multiple ways to define heads and tails.” EurekAlert! https://www.eurekalert.org/news-releases/1139020

Featured image: A fruit fly, the model species against which the moth fly’s development is compared.

Leave a Reply

Trending